PrestigePEO: Profile and What to Verify
PrestigePEO is a founder-led mid-market PEO out of Melville, New York - founded 1998, holding all three major accreditations (IRS CPEO, ESAC, and CI workers-comp risk management), licensed in all 50 states, and built deliberately around insurance brokers rather than direct sales.
At a glance
| Field | Detail |
|---|---|
| Founded | 1998, by Andrew Lubash (still founder-led) |
| Legal name | Prestige Employee Administrators |
| Headquarters | Melville, New York |
| Accreditations | IRS CPEO (2017 cohort), ESAC, and CI Workers Comp Risk Management - holds all three |
| Footprint | Licensed in all 50 states |
| Market focus | Roughly 10 to 500 employee companies |
| Channel | Sells through insurance brokers; states it will not accept Broker of Record letters |
| Ownership | TriSpan majority stake (January 2021); Lead Edge Capital continuation capital reported 2025 |
| Retirement plan | Pooled 401(k) reported near $700M in assets (industry review figure) |
| Worksite employees | Not published anywhere we could find - treated as not verified |
| Published pricing | None; quote-only |
Checked 2026-08-25 against prestigepeo.com (about/history pages), a TriSpan press release (2023), CB Insights and PitchBook profiles.
What they offer
The differentiator is the combination: rare triple accreditation, large-group medical access, a pooled 401(k), dedicated service pods - wrapped in a channel model where your insurance broker introduces the deal and stays compensated. That alignment cuts both ways: brokers advocate well, but you should still price the bundle against direct competitors.
Who fits
Broker-introduced SMBs of 10-500 employees that value white-glove service and accreditation depth over software polish. Purely domestic - no international capability.
Verify before signing
- CPEO entity match on your agreement - certification explainer.
- Broker commission structure disclosed in writing, so total cost is visible.
- Renewal mechanics and exit terms - clauses guide.
- Workers comp handling under the CI program - class codes.
Next
Pages for this provider
Frequently asked
Is PrestigePEO accredited?
It holds all three: IRS CPEO certification, ESAC accreditation, and the CI workers-compensation risk management certification - a combination the company says fewer than 1% of PEOs hold.
How does PrestigePEO price?
Quote-only. There is no published rate card, so request unbundled quotes and compare using like-for-like frames.
Who owns PrestigePEO?
TriSpan took a majority stake in January 2021; Lead Edge Capital led a continuation investment reported in 2025. Founder Andrew Lubash remains CEO.
Get matched with up to three PEOs
Answer six questions about your headcount, states and timeline. We shortlist providers that can actually serve you, and you choose which ones may contact you.
No obligation. You pick which providers get your details. We never sell your information to a data broker.